Thursday, 1 February 2024

Why the Riwaayataan for The Same Alleged Qira'at of Asim have differences in at least 408 Aayaat?

For the detailed post with many linked tables, evidences and comparisons, visit:
Alleged Variant Readings of The Quran

Note that قراءة حفص عن عاصم is the Qira'at according to the قراءة عامّة or قراءة عامّة المسلمين or الرواية الصحيحة المتواترة بين المسلمين recited by the Muslim masses through the ages, which is the Qira'at according to The Qur'an and thus it is referred to as The Qur'an and the other alleged alternate readings are referred to as alleged variant readings.

Alleged Variant Readings are different Modes / Dialects ? Excuse me! Then why are there at least 408 Aayaat where the same mode / dialect has differences?

In the following table, I linked up 408 Aayaat of The Qur'an, where Hafs from Asim differs from Shu'bah from Asim. With all due respect, the baseless claim of the celebrity scholars, that there is only 1 so called mutawaatir Qira'at of Asim involved here, and Hafs from Asim and Shu'bah from Asim are just 2 Riwaayahs (Riwaayataan) (with so called sahih isnad) for the same so called mutawaatir Qira'at, is completely exposed for anyone who has not yet shut down his reasoning and intellect (I can't do anything about those fans, who are impressed by follower count more than the evidences presented). Note that the celebrity scholars didn't claim that there were 2 Qira'at from Asim, and Hafs is Rawi for 1 Qira'at and Shu'bah is Rawi for the 2nd Qira'at, instead their claim implied that the Qira'at of Asim is a mutawaatir Qira'at with 408 or even more differences in only the direct Riwaayat for Asim's Qira'at by Hafs and Shu'bah. Anyway, since Hafs followed The Qur'an, in each and every case of difference between Hafs and Shu'bah, Hafs is correct.

ReferenceArabicEnglish
2:67.2.67.a.2.67.e
2:85.2.85.a.2.85.e
2:97.2.97.a.2.97.e
2:98.2.98.a.2.98.e
2:140.2.140.a.2.140.e
2:143.2.143.a.2.143.e
2:169.2.169.a.2.169.e
2:177.2.177.a.2.177.e
2:182.2.182.a.2.182.e
2:185.2.185.a.2.185.e
2:189.2.189.a.2.189.e
2:207.2.207.a.2.207.e
2:208.2.208.a.2.208.e
2:222.2.222.a.2.222.e
2:231.2.231.a.2.231.e
2:236.2.236.a.2.236.e
2:240.2.240.a.2.240.e
2:245.2.245.a.2.245.e
2:260.2.260.a.2.260.e
2:271.2.271.a.2.271.e
2:279.2.279.a.2.279.e
3:15.3.15.a.3.15.e
3:27.3.27.a.3.27.e
3:30.3.30.a.3.30.e
3:36.3.36.a.3.36.e
3:37.3.37.a.3.37.e
3:38.3.38.a.3.38.e
3:49.3.49.a.3.49.e
3:57.3.57.a.3.57.e
3:83.3.83.a.3.83.e
3:97.3.97.a.3.97.e
3:115.3.115.a.3.115.e
3:140.3.140.a.3.140.e
3:154.3.154.a.3.154.e
3:157.3.157.a.3.157.e
3:162.3.162.a.3.162.e
3:172.3.172.a.3.172.e
3:174.3.174.a.3.174.e
3:187.3.187.a.3.187.e
4:10.4.10.a.4.10.e
4:11.4.11.a.4.11.e
4:15.4.15.a.4.15.e
4:19.4.19.a.4.19.e
4:24.4.24.a.4.24.e
4:25.4.25.a.4.25.e
4:58.4.58.a.4.58.e
4:73.4.73.a.4.73.e
4:124.4.124.a.4.124.e
4:152.4.152.a.4.152.e
5:2.5.2.a.5.2.e
5:6.5.6.a.5.6.e
5:8.5.8.a.5.8.e
5:57.5.57.a.5.57.e
5:58.5.58.a.5.58.e
5:67.5.67.a.5.67.e
5:89.5.89.a.5.89.e
5:107.5.107.a.5.107.e
5:109.5.109.a.5.109.e
5:116.5.116.a.5.116.e
6:16.6.16.a.6.16.e
6:23.6.23.a.6.23.e
6:27.6.27.a.6.27.e
6:32.6.32.a.6.32.e
6:55.6.55.a.6.55.e
6:63.6.63.a.6.63.e
6:85.6.85.a.6.85.e
6:92.6.92.a.6.92.e
6:94.6.94.a.6.94.e
6:95.6.95.a.6.95.e
6:109.6.109.a.6.109.e
6:114.6.114.a.6.114.e
6:119.6.119.a.6.119.e
6:124.6.124.a.6.124.e
6:125.6.125.a.6.125.e
6:128.6.128.a.6.128.e
6:135.6.135.a.6.135.e
6:142.6.142.a.6.142.e
6:152.6.152.a.6.152.e
7:3.7.3.a.7.3.e
7:38.7.38.a.7.38.e
7:54.7.54.a.7.54.e
7:55.7.55.a.7.55.e
7:57.7.57.a.7.57.e
7:69.7.69.a.7.69.e
7:74.7.74.a.7.74.e
7:81.7.81.a.7.81.e
7:113.7.113.a.7.113.e
7:117.7.117.a.7.117.e
7:137.7.137.a.7.137.e
7:150.7.150.a.7.150.e
7:164.7.164.a.7.164.e
7:169.7.169.a.7.169.e
7:170.7.170.a.7.170.e
7:190.7.190.a.7.190.e
8:18.8.18.a.8.18.e
8:19.8.19.a.8.19.e
8:42.8.42.a.8.42.e
8:59.8.59.a.8.59.e
8:61.8.61.a.8.61.e
9:21.9.21.a.9.21.e
9:24.9.24.a.9.24.e
9:37.9.37.a.9.37.e
9:72.9.72.a.9.72.e
9:78.9.78.a.9.78.e
9:103.9.103.a.9.103.e
9:106.9.106.a.9.106.e
9:109.9.109.a.9.109.e
9:110.9.110.a.9.110.e
9:117.9.117.a.9.117.e
9:128.9.128.a.9.128.e
10:3.10.3.a.10.3.e
10:5.10.5.a.10.5.e
10:23.10.23.a.10.23.e
10:31.10.31.a.10.31.e
10:35.10.35.a.10.35.e
10:45.10.45.a.10.45.e
10:87.10.87.a.10.87.e
10:100.10.100.a.10.100.e
10:103.10.103.a.10.103.e
11:24.11.24.a.11.24.e
11:28.11.28.a.11.28.e
11:30.11.30.a.11.30.e
11:40.11.40.a.11.40.e
11:41.11.41.a.11.41.e
11:68.11.68.a.11.68.e
11:71.11.71.a.11.71.e
11:87.11.87.a.11.87.e
11:93.11.93.a.11.93.e
11:108.11.108.a.11.108.e
11:111.11.111.a.11.111.e
11:121.11.121.a.11.121.e
11:123.11.123.a.11.123.e
12:5.12.5.a.12.5.e
12:47.12.47.a.12.47.e
12:62.12.62.a.12.62.e
12:64.12.64.a.12.64.e
12:109.12.109.a.12.109.e
13:3.13.3.a.13.3.e
13:16.13.16.a.13.16.e
13:17.13.17.a.13.17.e
15:8.15.8.a.15.8.e
15:44.15.44.a.15.44.e
15:45.15.45.a.15.45.e
15:60.15.60.a.15.60.e
15:82.15.82.a.15.82.e
16:7.16.7.a.16.7.e
16:11.16.11.a.16.11.e
16:12.16.12.a.16.12.e
16:17.16.17.a.16.17.e
16:43.16.43.a.16.43.e
16:47.16.47.a.16.47.e
16:66.16.66.a.16.66.e
16:68.16.68.a.16.68.e
16:71.16.71.a.16.71.e
16:80.16.80.a.16.80.e
16:90.16.90.a.16.90.e
17:7.17.7.a.17.7.e
17:23.17.23.a.17.23.e
17:35.17.35.a.17.35.e
17:42.17.42.a.17.42.e
17:44.17.44.a.17.44.e
17:64.17.64.a.17.64.e
17:76.17.76.a.17.76.e
18:1.18.1.a.18.1.e
18:2.18.2.a.18.2.e
18:19.18.19.a.18.19.e
18:56.18.56.a.18.56.e
18:59.18.59.a.18.59.e
18:63.18.63.a.18.63.e
18:74.18.74.a.18.74.e
18:76.18.76.a.18.76.e
18:86.18.86.a.18.86.e
18:93.18.93.a.18.93.e
18:94.18.94.a.18.94.e
18:96.18.96.a.18.96.e
18:106.18.106.a.18.106.e
19:2.19.2.a.19.2.e
19:7.19.7.a.19.7.e
19:8.19.8.a.19.8.e
19:23.19.23.a.19.23.e
19:24.19.24.a.19.24.e
19:25.19.25.a.19.25.e
19:60.19.60.a.19.60.e
19:66.19.66.a.19.66.e
19:90.19.90.a.19.90.e
20:61.20.61.a.20.61.e
20:63.20.63.a.20.63.e
20:69.20.69.a.20.69.e
20:94.20.94.a.20.94.e
20:119.20.119.a.20.119.e
20:130.20.130.a.20.130.e
20:133.20.133.a.20.133.e
21:4.21.4.a.21.4.e
21:7.21.7.a.21.7.e
21:25.21.25.a.21.25.e
21:34.21.34.a.21.34.e
21:36.21.36.a.21.36.e
21:67.21.67.a.21.67.e
21:80.21.80.a.21.80.e
21:88.21.88.a.21.88.e
21:89.21.89.a.21.89.e
21:95.21.95.a.21.95.e
21:104.21.104.a.21.104.e
21:112.21.112.a.21.112.e
22:23.22.23.a.22.23.e
22:25.22.25.a.22.25.e
22:29.22.29.a.22.29.e
22:39.22.39.a.22.39.e
22:62.22.62.a.22.62.e
22:65.22.65.a.22.65.e
23:14.23.14.a.23.14.e
23:27.23.27.a.23.27.e
23:29.23.29.a.23.29.e
23:35.23.35.a.23.35.e
23:82.23.82.a.23.82.e
23:85.23.85.a.23.85.e
23:92.23.92.a.23.92.e
24:1.24.1.a.24.1.e
24:6.24.6.a.24.6.e
24:9.24.9.a.24.9.e
24:20.24.20.a.24.20.e
24:21.24.21.a.24.21.e
24:27.24.27.a.24.27.e
24:29.24.29.a.24.29.e
24:31.24.31.a.24.31.e
24:34.24.34.a.24.34.e
24:35.24.35.a.24.35.e
24:36.24.36.a.24.36.e
24:46.24.46.a.24.46.e
24:55.24.55.a.24.55.e
24:58.24.58.a.24.58.e
24:61.24.61.a.24.61.e
25:10.25.10.a.25.10.e
25:17.25.17.a.25.17.e
25:19.25.19.a.25.19.e
25:38.25.38.a.25.38.e
25:41.25.41.a.25.41.e
25:69.25.69.a.25.69.e
25:74.25.74.a.25.74.e
25:75.25.75.a.25.75.e
26:45.26.45.a.26.45.e
26:57.26.57.a.26.57.e
26:134.26.134.a.26.134.e
26:147.26.147.a.26.147.e
26:149.26.149.a.26.149.e
26:182.26.182.a.26.182.e
26:187.26.187.a.26.187.e
26:193.26.193.a.26.193.e
27:25.27.25.a.27.25.e
27:49.27.49.a.27.49.e
27:52.27.52.a.27.52.e
27:57.27.57.a.27.57.e
27:87.27.87.a.27.87.e
27:93.27.93.a.27.93.e
28:32.28.32.a.28.32.e
28:82.28.82.a.28.82.e
29:19.29.19.a.29.19.e
29:25.29.25.a.29.25.e
29:28.29.28.a.29.28.e
29:33.29.33.a.29.33.e
29:38.29.38.a.29.38.e
29:41.29.41.a.29.41.e
29:50.29.50.a.29.50.e
29:57.29.57.a.29.57.e
30:11.30.11.a.30.11.e
30:19.30.19.a.30.19.e
30:22.30.22.a.30.22.e
30:50.30.50.a.30.50.e
31:6.31.6.a.31.6.e
31:13.31.13.a.31.13.e
31:16.31.16.a.31.16.e
31:17.31.17.a.31.17.e
31:20.31.20.a.31.20.e
31:30.31.30.a.31.30.e
33:13.33.13.a.33.13.e
33:30.33.30.a.33.30.e
33:33.33.33.a.33.33.e
33:34.33.34.a.33.34.e
33:51.33.51.a.33.51.e
33:53.33.53.a.33.53.e
34:5.34.5.a.34.5.e
34:9.34.9.a.34.9.e
34:12.34.12.a.34.12.e
34:15.34.15.a.34.15.e
34:17.34.17.a.34.17.e
34:40.34.40.a.34.40.e
34:48.34.48.a.34.48.e
34:52.34.52.a.34.52.e
35:9.35.9.a.35.9.e
35:40.35.40.a.35.40.e
36:5.36.5.a.36.5.e
36:9.36.9.a.36.9.e
36:14.36.14.a.36.14.e
36:34.36.34.a.36.34.e
36:35.36.35.a.36.35.e
36:52.36.52.a.36.52.e
36:67.36.67.a.36.67.e
37:6.37.6.a.37.6.e
37:8.37.8.a.37.8.e
37:16.37.16.a.37.16.e
37:53.37.53.a.37.53.e
37:102.37.102.a.37.102.e
37:126.37.126.a.37.126.e
37:155.37.155.a.37.155.e
38:57.38.57.a.38.57.e
39:39.39.39.a.39.39.e
39:61.39.61.a.39.61.e
40:26.40.26.a.40.26.e
40:37.40.37.a.40.37.e
40:40.40.40.a.40.40.e
40:46.40.46.a.40.46.e
40:60.40.60.a.40.60.e
40:67.40.67.a.40.67.e
41:29.41.29.a.41.29.e
41:47.41.47.a.41.47.e
42:5.42.5.a.42.5.e
42:25.42.25.a.42.25.e
43:15.43.15.a.43.15.e
43:18.43.18.a.43.18.e
43:33.43.33.a.43.33.e
43:34.43.34.a.43.34.e
43:38.43.38.a.43.38.e
43:53.43.53.a.43.53.e
43:71.43.71.a.43.71.e
44:25.44.25.a.44.25.e
44:45.44.45.a.44.45.e
44:52.44.52.a.44.52.e
45:6.45.6.a.45.6.e
45:9.45.9.a.45.9.e
45:11.45.11.a.45.11.e
45:21.45.21.a.45.21.e
45:23.45.23.a.45.23.e
45:35.45.35.a.45.35.e
46:16.46.16.a.46.16.e
46:17.46.17.a.46.17.e
47:4.47.4.a.47.4.e
47:26.47.26.a.47.26.e
47:28.47.28.a.47.28.e
47:31.47.31.a.47.31.e
47:35.47.35.a.47.35.e
48:10.48.10.a.48.10.e
48:29.48.29.a.48.29.e
50:3.50.3.a.50.3.e
50:30.50.30.a.50.30.e
51:15.51.15.a.51.15.e
51:23.51.23.a.51.23.e
51:49.51.49.a.51.49.e
52:37.52.37.a.52.37.e
54:12.54.12.a.54.12.e
55:24.55.24.a.55.24.e
56:37.56.37.a.56.37.e
56:47.56.47.a.56.47.e
56:62.56.62.a.56.62.e
56:66.56.66.a.56.66.e
57:9.57.9.a.57.9.e
57:16.57.16.a.57.16.e
57:18.57.18.a.57.18.e
57:20.57.20.a.57.20.e
57:27.57.27.a.57.27.e
58:11.58.11.a.58.11.e
59:2.59.2.a.59.2.e
59:8.59.8.a.59.8.e
59:10.59.10.a.59.10.e
61:8.61.8.a.61.8.e
63:11.63.11.a.63.11.e
65:1.65.1.a.65.1.e
65:3.65.3.a.65.3.e
65:8.65.8.a.65.8.e
65:11.65.11.a.65.11.e
66:4.66.4.a.66.4.e
66:8.66.8.a.66.8.e
66:12.66.12.a.66.12.e
70:16.70.16.a.70.16.e
70:33.70.33.a.70.33.e
70:43.70.43.a.70.43.e
72:3.72.3.a.72.3.e
72:4.72.4.a.72.4.e
72:5.72.5.a.72.5.e
72:6.72.6.a.72.6.e
72:7.72.7.a.72.7.e
72:8.72.8.a.72.8.e
72:9.72.9.a.72.9.e
72:10.72.10.a.72.10.e
72:11.72.11.a.72.11.e
72:12.72.12.a.72.12.e
72:14.72.14.a.72.14.e
72:19.72.19.a.72.19.e
73:9.73.9.a.73.9.e
74:5.74.5.a.74.5.e
74:33.74.33.a.74.33.e
75:27.75.27.a.75.27.e
75:37.75.37.a.75.37.e
76:4.76.4.a.76.4.e
76:15.76.15.a.76.15.e
76:16.76.16.a.76.16.e
76:21.76.21.a.76.21.e
77:6.77.6.a.77.6.e
77:33.77.33.a.77.33.e
77:41.77.41.a.77.41.e
78:25.78.25.a.78.25.e
79:11.79.11.a.79.11.e
81:12.81.12.a.81.12.e
83:14.83.14.a.83.14.e
83:31.83.31.a.83.31.e
88:4.88.4.a.88.4.e
104:8.104.8.a.104.8.e
104:9.104.9.a.104.9.e
112:4.112.4.a.112.4.e

Appendix:
Short Clip where Dr. Shahzad Saleem Explains How Hafs is Accurate because it followed the Quran.

Since a video from Abu Layth's Channel is posted, just because I could not find another short video of Shahzad Saleem on this issue, the following video should also be seen once before anyone thinks of seeing more videos from Abu Layth's channel:
Islam according to Abu Layth.